Stranded with Legends

We Win, or We Die.

Patricia wrote:We Win, or We Die.

Yep!

Hey guys! We need to determine who should sit out. Is anyone not here? That would make it easy...

I think we can do this fairly strategically. IDC who picks our five peeps, but this is the strategy we should use to figure out their combination.

Step #1. For your first attempt, select one color, then put four of those pegs on the board. (If you like red, play R-R-R-R.)

Your opponent will then have to indicate whether or not any red pieces are in the solution. If he/she does not put down any pegs, that means there are no red pegs in the solution, and you do not have to guess red for the remainder of the game.

However, if there are red pegs in the solution, he will have to tell you how many there are.

Step #2. If you get no pegs for the first attempt, select another color, and put four of those pegs on the board for your second attempt.

However, say for instance, you know from your first attempt that there is one red peg in the solution. Your second guess will accomplish two purposes: 1) try to guess the position of the red peg, and 2) try to determine if the next color is present in the solution.

Put the red peg in the first position, then select another color (orange) and fill the remaining three positions. The incremental change in the total number correct is the count of orange pegs in the solution. (If your opponent puts down 1 indicator for the first step, and 3 for the second step, you know that there are two orange pegs (three minus one) in the solution. If there is still only one indicator for the second step, there are zero orange pegs (one minus one) in the solution.)

Another clue can be distilled by counting the number of white pegs (right color, wrong position) your opponent puts out. Say, for instance, that in step #1, you found out that there is one red peg. In step #2, if your opponent puts out zero white pegs, you know that the red peg is in the correct position. If he puts out one white peg, you know that the red peg is in the wrong position. If he puts out two white pegs, you know that the orange peg belongs in the place that the red peg is currently in.

Step #3: Basically, step #3 is similar to step #2. At this point, you will know how many red and orange pieces belong in the solution. Move on to the next color (if necessary) and make another guess. If you know there is one red and one orange piece, put a red, an orange, and two yellows, and try to guess the position of the red and orange. If there is one orange piece and zero red pieces, try one orange and three yellows.

After step #3, you just keep trying to determine the color components and the order of these components. Just repeat step #3, but use your additional knowledge to make further deductions.

I don't know if I am making myself clear or not, but here is the intent of this strategy:

Part 1 - find out what colors are in the solution, and in what quantity.
Part 2 - find out the order of the colors in the solution

If you can combine parts 1 and 2, you will come up with the strategy I have outlined above.

I guess whoever is leader can follow all of those steps.

this challenge makes my head hurt i can sit out

We don't get to sit anyone out.

I vote Willard to be our leader then.

Naonka wrote:I guess whoever is leader can follow all of those steps.

Who is our leader for this challenge? haha

Probably you. :o

I'll do it, but I'm not a quicker poster. It looks like the tiebreaker is whoever posts their combination faster.

People on the other tribe for your guesses:

Sarah
Ami
Taj
Paloma
Rudy
Brenda
Frank
Gina

I don't care who does it I just thought Willard would want to do it since he seems the most knowledgable about this type of challenge. But we need to pick our combination.

Cirie was elected our tribe leader the other day, that's why she has to do it.

How about

Cirie
Teresa
Patricia
Gregg
John

as our combination?

Is John here? If not, we should sit him out over Gregg.

Willard wrote:Cirie was elected our tribe leader the other day, that's why she has to do it.

How about

Cirie
Teresa
Patricia
Gregg
John

as our combination?

OK lets do it.

K cool. Cirie, we don't get to sit anyone out since we have less people than the other tribe I think.

Willard wrote:K cool. Cirie, we don't get to sit anyone out since we have less people than the other tribe I think.

Oh shoot! Thanks! I misread Jeff's directions there.

Do you understand the process for this challenge Cirie? I just want to make sure you're clear on it before it starts since it'll be pretty fast.

Yeah, Willard. I think I do. I'll keep checking, just to see if something is off.

Nice work Cirie!

Yeah, Willard. I think I do. I'll keep checking, just to see if something is off.

So now do something like Sarah-Frank-Frank-Frank-Frank

Cool you totes got this, I'll stop throwing you off.